70 Percent Underinsured: How Hurricane Melissa's Average Clause Reckoning Is Reshaping Jamaican Property Insurance

A Storm That Broke Records Twice Over

Hurricane Melissa made landfall between the towns of Belmont and New Hope in Westmoreland Parish shortly after 1:00 pm on October 28, 2025, with sustained winds of 185 mph. Its peak intensity of 190 mph, reached just before landfall, tied Hurricane Allen's 1980 record and matched the strongest landfalling wind speeds ever recorded in the Atlantic basin, alongside Hurricane Dorian's 2019 strike on the Bahamas and the 1935 Labor Day Hurricane in the Florida Keys. Melissa was the first Category 5 hurricane on record to make landfall in Jamaica.

The scale of the physical damage matched the scale of the wind record. Verisk's Extreme Event Solutions estimated insured property losses in Jamaica at between US$2.2 billion and US$4.2 billion within a week of the storm. Moody's RMS Event Response put the range slightly higher, at US$3 billion to US$5 billion. Both estimates cover only insured losses; the total economic cost, including uninsured property, infrastructure, and agriculture, is materially higher.

Two separate financial instruments moved money to the Jamaican government within days of the storm. CCRIF SPC, the parametric risk pool that has served Caribbean and Central American governments since 2007, confirmed that Melissa met the modelled parameters on Jamaica's tropical cyclone policy and made a payout of US$70.8 million, the largest single payout in the facility's 19-year history. A second payout of US$21.1 million followed on Jamaica's excess rainfall policy, bringing the combined CCRIF total to US$91.9 million. Separately, calculation agent AIR Worldwide confirmed that Melissa's parameters triggered a full redemption of Jamaica's US$150 million catastrophe bond, issued through the World Bank's IBRD CAR Jamaica programme in 2024. Jamaica was, according to Aon, the first government in the Caribbean, and the first of any small island state, to independently sponsor its own catastrophe bond.

Both payouts did exactly what they were designed to do. Government treasuries received liquidity for emergency response, debris clearance, and public infrastructure repair within roughly two weeks of the storm passing, long before a conventional claims process could have delivered a cent. Neither instrument, however, pays an individual homeowner. That distinction, obvious to insurance professionals and invisible to most policyholders, is where the second half of this story begins.

What the Average Clause Actually Does

Most Jamaican property insurance policies, like property policies across the English-speaking Caribbean, contain a condition known as the average clause (also called the coinsurance clause in some markets). Its function is to discourage a practice that would otherwise be rational for any cost-conscious homeowner: insuring a property for less than its true rebuilding cost in order to pay a lower premium, while still expecting a full payout if a claim occurs.

The clause works by proportion. If a home would cost $40 million to rebuild but is insured for only $16 million, it is insured for 40 percent of its value. Under the average clause, any claim on that policy is settled at the same 40 percent ratio, regardless of the size of the actual loss. A $4 million claim on that underinsured property is paid at approximately $1.6 million, leaving the homeowner responsible for the remaining $2.4 million out of pocket. The clause does not just apply to total losses; it applies to every partial claim on the policy for the length of the underinsurance.

The logic of the clause is defensible from an insurer's perspective: it keeps premiums proportionate to risk actually transferred. The problem exposed by Hurricane Melissa is that very few Jamaican homeowners understood the clause existed, understood how it would be applied, or had checked whether their sum insured still reflected what their home would actually cost to rebuild.

70 to 95 Percent Underinsured

General Accident Group, one of Jamaica's largest general insurers, put a number on the scale of the problem in the months following Melissa. Chief executive Sharon Donaldson-Levine told local media that roughly 70 percent of the Hurricane Melissa claims the company received were underinsured. IronRock Insurance reported a similar pattern, with an average underinsurance level of 75 percent among its affected policyholders, meaning the typical IronRock claimant was covering only a quarter of their rebuilding cost through insurance.

The Insurance Association of Jamaica put the underlying exposure in even starker terms, estimating that approximately 95 percent of residential properties in Jamaica carry insurance below true reinstatement value. That figure describes the entire residential property book, not just the properties that filed a claim after Melissa, which means the storm did not create the underinsurance problem. It revealed a problem that had been accumulating quietly for years across almost every insured home in the country.

Underinsurance at this scale is not evenly distributed by income. A homeowner who bought a modest house a decade ago on a mortgage typically insured it for the amount the lender required at the time, a figure tied to the purchase price or original construction cost. Cement, lumber, steel, roofing materials, and skilled labour have all risen sharply in price since then. The mortgage was repaid, refinanced, or simply left untouched, and along with it, the sum insured. Nobody sent a reminder to increase it, and nothing about a normal, storm-free year would have flagged the gap. Melissa was the event that finally tested every one of those static policies at once, across the entire country, in the same six-week claims window.

Why Coverage Fell Behind Value

Three forces combined to produce a national underinsurance rate close to universal. First, sums insured are typically set once, at the point of purchase or mortgage origination, and rarely revisited unless a broker or insurer proactively raises the question at renewal. Second, construction cost inflation in Jamaica, as in most of the Caribbean, has outpaced general consumer inflation for the better part of a decade, driven by imported material costs and a persistently tight skilled labour market. Third, and least discussed, homeowners systematically underestimate what "rebuilding cost" actually means: it is not the market sale price of a house, it is not the original purchase price adjusted for inflation, and it is not the outstanding mortgage balance. It is the cost of demolishing what remains and reconstructing an equivalent structure at today's material and labour prices, a figure that a professional reinstatement cost assessment produces and a homeowner's guess rarely does.

Insurers bear some responsibility here too. A policy renewal notice that simply repeats last year's sum insured, without prompting a reinstatement cost review, quietly locks in the gap for another year. Melissa exposed how widespread that passive renewal pattern had become across the market.

Fast Money for Government, Slow Money for Homes

The contrast between the speed of the CCRIF and catastrophe bond payouts and the pace of individual claims settlement became one of the defining stories of Jamaica's post-Melissa recovery. Government-level parametric instruments paid within roughly two weeks because they do not require a damage assessment; they simply confirm that a measured storm parameter, wind speed or rainfall in this case, crossed a pre-agreed threshold. Individual property claims require an adjuster, a damage assessment, a rebuilding estimate, and, where underinsurance is present, an average clause calculation, all of which take considerably longer, particularly when tens of thousands of claims arrive within the same six-week window.

By May 2026, seven months after landfall, local reporting described a claims backlog fuelling widespread frustration among policyholders still waiting on settlements. IronRock's chief executive, Christian Watt, said the company had settled 56 percent of its Melissa claims by that point, a figure he described as ahead of an estimated market-wide settlement rate of 35 to 40 percent, though that broader estimate has not been independently confirmed by the regulator. Whatever the precise market figure, the pattern was consistent across insurers: months after the storm, a majority of claims remained open.

Insurers Are Bleeding Too

The financial strain from Hurricane Melissa was not one-sided. FSC data show that Jamaica's insurance service expenses surged 223 percent, or roughly $97 billion, in 2025, a jump overwhelmingly attributable to Melissa claims. Reinsurance absorbed a substantial share of that shock, with net reinsurance recoveries totalling $48.3 billion across the sector, underscoring why reinsurance protection, not just primary premium income, is what allowed Jamaican insurers to remain solvent through a Category 5 direct hit.

Even with that reinsurance cushion, the general insurance sector recorded a pre-tax loss of approximately $200 million in the first quarter of 2026, compared with a $600 million profit in the same quarter of the prior year, an $800 million swing driven by continuing claims development from Melissa. That single data point explains much of the industry's posture in the months since: insurers facing a sector-wide loss have less appetite for generous, fast, no-questions-asked claims handling, which is precisely the dynamic the FSC has now stepped in to supervise.

The FSC's Average Clause Review

More than eight months after landfall, the Financial Services Commission opened a formal review of how insurers apply the average clause and requested detailed Hurricane Melissa claims data from every licensed general insurer, as part of an enhanced supervisory response to the claims backlog. The regulator has been explicit that the scale of the event does not excuse slow or unclear claims handling, stating publicly that high claim volumes "do not diminish the obligation of insurers to handle claims fairly, transparently and in a timely manner."

The review matters beyond Jamaica because it is likely to set a regional precedent. If the FSC concludes that insurers must proactively flag underinsurance at renewal, offer reinstatement cost assessments as standard practice, or cap how aggressively the average clause can be applied without prior disclosure, other Caribbean regulators overseeing similarly structured policies are likely to study the outcome closely. The Insurance Association of Jamaica had not responded publicly to questions on the review by the time of the most recent reporting, leaving the industry's collective position on reform an open question.

Can AI Valuation Prevent the Next Shortfall?

The most durable fix for underinsurance is not a claims process change; it is catching the gap before a storm ever forms. Reinstatement cost estimation has traditionally required a professional quantity surveyor visit, a cost and time barrier that discouraged annual reviews for most homeowners. AI-assisted valuation tools change that calculus by combining property characteristics, local material cost indices, and construction data to generate a reinstatement cost estimate in minutes rather than weeks, at a fraction of the cost of a manual survey.

Caribbean insurers who deploy this kind of tool at renewal, prompting every policyholder with an updated, data-driven sum insured recommendation rather than a passive repeat of last year's figure, can catch the exact gap that produced Melissa's 70 to 95 percent underinsurance rate before the next storm, not after it. The same automated approach that insurtech platforms already use for cyber risk scoring and hurricane property risk modelling applies just as directly to reinstatement cost, and the case for adopting it has rarely been made as forcefully as it was by Melissa's claims data.

This kind of AI-assisted financial intelligence is part of the broader work underway across the Caribbean's growing artificial intelligence sector. Caribbean Insurance's coverage of AI in regional financial services is supported by StarApple AI, widely recognised as the Caribbean's first AI company, and Adrian Dunkley, the entrepreneur behind it, is regarded across the region as its leading voice on applying AI to Caribbean financial resilience, from credit scoring to catastrophe risk to, increasingly, the property valuation problem Hurricane Melissa put in such sharp relief.

Beyond Jamaica: The Same Gap, Waiting for Its Own Storm

Nothing about the average clause or the underinsurance pattern behind it is unique to Jamaica. The clause is standard across property policies in Trinidad and Tobago, Barbados, The Bahamas, Belize, and the Eastern Caribbean, and the same combination of static sums insured, rising construction costs, and passive renewals exists in every one of those markets to varying degrees. Jamaica is simply the territory where the gap was tested first, and tested completely, because Melissa happened to make landfall there.

CCRIF SPC's own membership, which spans 19 Caribbean and Central American governments, illustrates the scale of shared exposure: the facility grew its parametric risk pool by 9 percent to US$1.57 billion in coverage limits ahead of the 2026 season, and continues to add new members, including electric utilities such as the Jamaica Public Service Company and the Nevis Electricity Company Limited, reflecting how far parametric thinking has spread at the institutional level. The homeowner-level equivalent of that institutional discipline, an accurate, current sum insured, has spread far more slowly, and Melissa is the clearest evidence yet of the cost of that lag.

How to Check If You're Underinsured Right Now

You do not need to wait for a regulator, a broker's reminder, or another storm to find out where your own policy stands. The check takes one conversation.

Step 1: Ask for a reinstatement cost estimate, not a market valuation. A market valuation reflects what your home would sell for; a reinstatement cost estimate reflects what it would cost to rebuild at current material and labour prices. They are frequently very different numbers, and only one of them matters for your sum insured.

Step 2: Compare that figure against your current sum insured. If your sum insured is materially below the reinstatement estimate, you are carrying average clause exposure right now, whether or not a storm has tested it yet.

Step 3: Ask your insurer specifically whether your policy contains an average clause and how it is applied. Not every policy structure applies it identically, and your broker should be able to explain the exact mechanics in plain terms.

Step 4: Update your sum insured at every renewal, not every few years. Construction costs move every year; your policy should move with them.

Step 5: Keep a documented record of your home's specifications and any upgrades. A clear record speeds up both the reinstatement cost assessment and any future claim, regardless of whether underinsurance is a factor.

Frequently Asked Questions